www.bestpubs.co.uk
 



Home 
Our Blog 
Search Whats On 
Search For Pubs 

------JOIN BESTPUBS------- 
Landlords 
Contributors 
Advertise 

-----SWITCH AREA TO------
Edinburgh 
East End 
Leith/Northside 
New Town 
Old Town 
Outlying 
Southside 
West End 
Midlothian 
Perth/Kinross/Fife 
Scottish Borders 
Stirling/Clackmannan 
West Lothian 

Search Other Areas 

--------SHORT CUTS--------- 
Contact Bestpubs 
Pub Books 
Cookies 


 Selected Comments in Leith/Northside

Anne Harvey-Chisholm
 A Luvly Pub
Stopped off here for a drink after our Water of Leith walk, and what a luvly pub, sat throught the back with comfy couches and an open fire, a great amosphere, people who I assume where locals chatting to each other from other tables, no music or tv in this area, a great place to chill and relax after our walk, the bar area was busy with locals, football on the tv, but a friendly welcoming pub with a really nice barmaid, recommend a visit, its a proper friendly pub with atmosphere
Wednesday, April 23, 2014Rating: rosettes

George
 It's reopened
All new @TheVintageLeith
Friday, March 8, 2013Rating: rosettes

Chris DaBurgh
 Pies of awesomeness
Steak pie boobies are a fitting moniker for these juggernauts of goodness. You won't find a better boobies anywhere else.
Friday, January 18, 2013Rating: rosettes

Numb Artist
 Food and service diabolical
This is a real shame as the pub is in one the pest locations for a sunday lunch.. bar staff and food service arrogant and make customers feel not wanted while they chatter to each other.. but food is simply AWFUL - they serve whatever they can get away with.. and if you complain they make out the customers is at fault... i cannot emphasise enough what a complete let down this place is.
Thursday, November 1, 2012Rating: No rosettes

Shane
 LADY GA GA
Went in with my partner saturday night
really nice atmosphere and the guy doing the lady ga ga was a right laugh.
had a great night.
Thursday, October 18, 2012Rating: rosettes

Simon
 Good
always a good crowd in at the weekend and very friendly with many ales on offer.
Saturday, October 6, 2012Rating: rosettes

Ex-Cleaner at the Noble
 Nineteen Sixties
Sort of gived it away
when i cleared the glasses away
...................Lipstick on most of them...............
Thursday, September 13, 2012Rating: rosettes

Dennis Scanes Alphington
 Pioneer
First Homosexual pub i ever visited during the sixties.
And it's thanks to The Noble and seeing it was ok tht i realisd i too was Homosexual.
Tuesday, September 11, 2012Rating: rosettes

Wigan Man
 Stick to making Whisky
Tried the Famous pie last Friday
and it was disapointing the pastry was rock hard and not much meat in filling.
Tuesday, September 4, 2012Rating: rosettes

Nick A.
 Great local!
Carriers is my favourite place in leith. Staff is always helpful and friendly. Great atmosphere. Never got a bad pint in there. Everybody seems to be complementing pies only but there is so much to it. Loads of different bottles and I think over 15 drafts... Great place.
Monday, September 3, 2012Rating: rosettes

Mat
 Living in the Past.
Ohhhhhhhhh grow up
That was nearly a quarter of a century ago.
The Pub has changed and now is a thriving pub for everyone and the food is really good and it's mostly families that come in. but everybody will get a real Edinburgh welcoming
Thursday, August 30, 2012Rating: rosettes

Vera
 Terrible
This pub is the reason i no longer have a father but a he/she who no longer wants to see his grandchildren and doesnt care about his family or the shame and humiliation he put my mother through
God rest her Soul.
Wednesday, August 29, 2012Rating: No rosettes

Roger Medland
 Fred ?
Anyone rememeber my Father
Fred Medland He was drag artist and singer
used to perform and the Noble a lot of saturday nights with Eric Searle.
Tuesday, August 28, 2012Rating: rosettes

Iris Watson
 Blast from the Past
Takes me back to my childhood
There was allsorts of rumours about the Noble
I Guess that's why they had the stained windows , to keep prying eyes out as you could still be jailed for being Homosexual.
My Uncle Ian who was homesexual loved this place and used to get me and my sister to do his make up before he went to the noble on a saturday night. A lot of the men were married anf terrified about their family finding out and used to store their dresses and wigs at the pub.
Friday, August 24, 2012Rating: rosettes

Trevor Bolt Haverfordwest.
 Well done
Blimey didnt know that !!!!
Well done to Nobles Bar and Scotland for having a gay bar during the 1940's and 1950's well ahead of their time.
Thursday, August 23, 2012Rating: rosettes

Dennis
 Pub On The Shore
Got a new Name for your Pub The WHORE ON THE SHORE
I am sure this is a better name
Sunday, August 12, 2012Rating: rosettes

Alan
 rubbish
waited over an hour for microwaved chips.
Friday, July 20, 2012Rating: rosettes

LEN DAVEY EXETER
 FUN PUB
sounds like my sort of pub
look forward to meeting the lassies
Monday, June 25, 2012Rating: rosettes

Bert Brown
 Horrible Bar
This is a Pub For Slack Woman who are After only One Thing Beware they Will Have your trousers Off and away with your Cash
Monday, June 25, 2012Rating: rosettes

Jackie Tabraham
 
It was our 1st visit to the old chain pier and first impressions were that it was well laid out and decorated, nice views etc however it went down hill from there. Stood for a while before I then had to ask where to sit and had to ask for menus.

We were very surprised at how tiny the portions were and food very average once it finally came. I would recommend for drinks only!!
Sunday, June 17, 2012Rating: rosettes

A shame about the food
 Bad food
A nice view but the chefs obviously do not care about the food they serve. Go for drinks only and eat somewhere else.
Thursday, June 7, 2012Rating: rosettes

unsatisfied customer
 service of no standard
waiters don't have a clue. took plates away while people will still eating - extra butter was thrown onto the table. asked to order a dessert, received the menu but the waiter never came back to ask if we'd like to order. not recommended for large groups. pie with veg - no veg to be seen only a few salad leaves. pity. they have an awful lot to learn.
Monday, June 4, 2012Rating: rosettes

willie
 good location
Great pub with a fantastic view.
Recommended for a quiet drink.
Thursday, May 17, 2012Rating: rosettes

Anonymous
 Best pub in Edinburgh
BEST PUB IN EDINBURGH!! If you go to the Iona you will always leave saying I've had a brilliant night! the regulars are very friendly and welcoming and jimmy & jack the owners are a lovely friendly couple who do all they can to make sure their cusomers are happy they r best couple I have meat in my life with hearts of gold. If you are ever in Edinburgh you can not visit the Iona bar on a Friday or sat for karaoke or a week night for a quiet drink!! Keep up the good work Jimmy & Jackie
Tuesday, January 24, 2012Rating: rosettes

louise
 brilliant couple
fantastic couple jackie and jimmy, been in the bar for years and its run very well, big congrats to them both x
Sunday, January 15, 2012Rating: rosettes

annon
 
fantastic bar.
Sunday, January 15, 2012Rating: rosettes

annon
 best bar by far
this is a fab bar, with friendly locals, staff are the best you can get and the banter is brill, karaoke on fri n sat, with darts n doms during the week so never a dull moment, both owners jackie and jimmy are friendly and helpful to all and a very nice couple with a nice family, i wish them both all the best in their ongoing success.
Monday, January 9, 2012Rating: rosettes

Nigel Watkins
 Never Again
I recently had an evening meal at the starbank with my girlfriend and was disgusted by the lack of hygiene that the person that served us had. the woman wearing black clothes was sweaty, had bad breath and smelled of BO! she was more interested in serving a large group than us. I am used to dining in fine eateries and this place is certainly not one. I was even thinking of complaining to Bellhaven over this but I was persauded not to by my girlfriend since it was christmas time..My girlfriend and I will not be returning. Nigel
Saturday, January 7, 2012Rating: No rosettes

P Hurley
 Good food
Great food as always and took our guests from Canada for a meal.
Only criticism would be the offputting couple who were getting a bit amorous in the corner. We made a complaint but the bar staff were not willing to do anything about this. It was a bit uncomfortable to say in the least!
Thursday, December 29, 2011Rating: rosettes

Anil
 Racist pub
Embarass humiliated Asian barred for not being served and again and again in Edinburgh are we going to allow this crazy man
Tuesday, November 15, 2011Rating: No rosettes

Anil
 Racist pub
Embarass humiliated Asian barred for not being served and again and again in Edinburgh are we going to allow this crazy man
Tuesday, November 15, 2011Rating: No rosettes

Mick Zaborav
 the Port
I can think of no better description than to say this is simply an institution.
Had it reverted to selling some of the best cask ales on the market, it would have the entire complement of rosettes from me. Idiosyncratic, historic, probably the finest collection of seafaring oddities in the country (I include the clientèle), it's as close to the perfect pub in any large port I've seen.
Friday, September 30, 2011Rating: rosettes

Nicola Barton
 Brilliant food, service and atmosphere
We went to the pub for some lunch and came away raving about the food, service and how nice an atmosphere the pub has. I had the steak burger which was one of the best burgers I have ever had. Amazing!!!
Friday, August 12, 2011Rating: rosettes

Jim
 Good pub poor staff
Gents toilets stick of bleach so much that it makes your eyes run. Rude barmaid who kept the door open to let freezing cold air in. The result was many people left, including me and friends. Perhaps that is what she wanted. Dreadful woman.
Sunday, March 27, 2011Rating: No rosettes

ellen and patsy
 
recent visitor to festival ale good but ladies loo a disaster no flush ugh !!
Friday, August 6, 2010Rating: rosettes

Lee John Ayres
 Zero customer service
Staff more interested in stacking fridges, collecting glasses or having a conversation with other staff than serving the customer.
Wednesday, June 30, 2010Rating: rosettes

Redfoot
 Marvellous old boozer
A classic real ale pub with great choice of well kept ales and v friendly staff. See the chalk board behind the bar for the raft of available ales and don't forget to try the malt of the moment. Going to leith tonight and will def be spending sometime unwinding here!
Wednesday, May 19, 2010Rating: rosettes

Redfoot
 Marvellous old bozer
A classic real ale pub with great choice of well kept ales and v friendly staff. See the chalk board behind the bar for the raft of available ales and don't forget to try the malt of the moment. Going to leith tonight and will def be spending sometime unwinding here!
Wednesday, May 19, 2010Rating: rosettes

Graeme Wallace
 Nobles Bar
My father owned Nobles Bar back in the late 1940s and early 1950s. Back then it was a men only drinking establishment, frequented by the workers from the dock area. The bar was in the centre of the room, but the stain glass windows look the same
Wednesday, April 28, 2010Rating: rosettes

Graeme Wallace
 Nobles Bar
My father owned Nobles Bar back in the late 1940s and early 1950s. Back then it was a men only drinking establishment, frequented by the workers from the dock area. The bar was in the centre of the room, but the stain glass windows look the same
Wednesday, April 28, 2010Rating: rosettes

Charlie P
 Quiz
There is a popular Pub Quiz held every Monday at 7:30 pm
Monday, April 26, 2010Rating: rosettes

Mais
 amazing pies
To be fair I was a bit sceptical about the pie, the comments made it sound like abit too good to be true...
after trying this amazing steak pie, I can never get enough, every day now I go down to Carriers for lunch to have me this amazing pie.

Its just so good! nothing can beat this pie!
Friday, January 29, 2010Rating: rosettes

Hotline
 Friday Pie Hotline
The friday pie hotline is 0131 554 4122. Make sure you don't miss out on what is definitely the greatest munch in the world.
Friday, December 11, 2009Rating: rosettes

Anonymous
 Amazing best place ever.
I highly recommend this pub/restraunt to anyone who likes fresh seafood.The best place i went to in Edinburgh definitely a highlight of my trip.
Wednesday, September 16, 2009Rating: rosettes

KAROLINA
 FRESH, NICE FOOD
Fresh food, good beer, very nice views, friendly service.
Very nice place for a Familly lunch/ dinner/ Family party
Wednesday, June 10, 2009Rating: rosettes

L33tm4n
 OMFG Pie Roolz
OMFG this pie iz awesum. It pwns so much. I luv pie. LOLOLOLOL!!!
Thursday, April 9, 2009Rating: rosettes

shtk pie
 best shtk pie in Edinburgh
If you love pies, shtk pies, then drop by Carriers in Leith (Edinburgh). The pies have some sort of magical shtk
Tuesday, March 3, 2009Rating: rosettes

Friday Pie Man
 
I love this great pub, it has excellent foodles. Monumental Friday pie can be found every Friday at Carriers Quarters.It also has other stuff like beer, music and people drinking. And eating pie.
Saturday, February 21, 2009Rating: rosettes

Awesome Friday pies
 Friday pies
If you are looking for Friday steak pies, then it doesnt matter if it's Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday or Friday. Pies in Carriers are always awesome. Steak pies take some time so better book in advance the Friday pies.
Thursday, February 19, 2009Rating: rosettes

Colin
 Carriers Quarters = Awesome Pie Headquarters
Are you looking for awesome pies? Well stop looking!! You've just found their headquarters!! It's a nice bar with a nice atmosphere, but mainly I go for the pies.
Friday, February 6, 2009Rating: rosettes

Steak Pie Bookbies Lover
 Steak Pie Boobies
I have to admit, I agree with every boby that has replied to this thread. Carrirers steak pie boobies are amazing. The boobie in the steak pie is simply perfect
Friday, February 6, 2009Rating: rosettes

T4YH
 
The Salmon sizzler with the chili sauce is fantastic.
Thursday, January 22, 2009Rating: rosettes

fab
 
ITS ALL BEEN SAID
Monday, December 29, 2008Rating: rosettes

Anonymous
 
Monday, December 29, 2008Rating: rosettes

Raymond Hogg
 Raymond
Great pie shop! Does any one know if it sells beer?
Thursday, December 11, 2008Rating: rosettes

JIMMY
 
to add to the last comment i must agree...and its even better now its been done up...well done to the staff and jackie and jimmy for the best local anyone could ask for and long may it last............
ONE VERY HAPPY CUSTOMER THANKS
Sunday, December 7, 2008Rating: No rosettes

darren
 darren
what a fab bar...friendly customers that like a laugh...fabby staff especially jackie and tracey who work a fri night...and when hibs are at home the staff always manage to handle the crowds 100% well done to jim and jackie for a well run bar
Sunday, December 7, 2008Rating: rosettes

LSMILNE
 this is shut
I spent £10 on a cab to meet a friend here on the basis of this website description - in fact it's shut and has been for a long time - so don't waste time and money on the trip
Friday, October 31, 2008Rating: No rosettes

JD
 Awesome Pie (the best ever) cures depretion
Carries serve the best steak pies i have ever had, the soup is great the nachos are good but the steak pie is utterly awesome, i've went into carries with sore bones and headaches and after i a pie i feel like the leaper jesus touched. Try the pie
Friday, September 12, 2008Rating: rosettes

I. Mackie
 Excellent
Despite a couple of bad reviews above, a one time bad experience does not a bad pub make. Forget the toilets, which are small and in need of decoration, this place is the definition of class. Great food, in both restaurant and bar. the slight rise in price (hardly double) is worth the extra level of service and the amazing selection of dishes. Maybe the menu isn't large, but it is clever. I visit this pub regularly and i have never had a bad meal or bad service. Plus the breakfasts are amazing.
Tuesday, August 19, 2008Rating: rosettes

Awesome Steak Pies
 Awesome Steak Pies
The Carriers Steak Pies are something that you shouldn't miss if you are in Leith. No doubt they are the best steak pies in UK.
Clean Leith raft with the awesome steak pies!
The steak pie and mash recipe is secret.
Wednesday, August 13, 2008Rating: rosettes

Awesome Pies
 Awesome Pie!!!
Awesome pies, yeah, this is the place for awesome steak pies.
Friday, August 8, 2008Rating: rosettes

Michael
 soup
I dont know about the Pie, but the soup is souptastic, soupelicious, infact if I can have intercourse with the soup I would get married her rightnow
Friday, July 25, 2008Rating: rosettes

Ibrahim
 The pie is awesome
Yeah, I totally agree with Lynx. Before I was blind but since I ate the Pie, I can see again!!
Friday, July 25, 2008Rating: rosettes

Lynx
 the pies are awesome!
Its a nice wee pub, the food is great, i highly recommend the pie, it has some sort of special healing powers... no kidding.
Friday, July 25, 2008Rating: rosettes

BROUGHTON HOTEL
 VERY DIRTY
THEY SAY YOU CAN JUDGE A PUB BY IT'S TOILETS IF THAT'S THE CASE I WOULD HATE TO SEE THIS PUBS KITCHENS DISPITE THE AWARD,
Tuesday, July 1, 2008Rating: rosettes

MR MUNRO
 
this is one of the best pubs in Easter Road, had a lot of great laughs, staff are great and the owner Jimmy looks like his pet dog (the boxer)
Saturday, February 10, 2007Rating: rosettes

Mike Tait
 The bar from star wars in the cosmopolitan Port of
Customer care trained bar staff. The best pint of Deuchars in the universe. Quiz nights where competition is high and cheating is rife. Lots of opportunities for rubberneckers and observers of human behaviour. And a talented football team (when they can get there act together to play).Oh, and Jamie the barman, the best guitar man in EH6.
Friday, October 20, 2006Rating: rosettes

Jimmy
 Live Music
Buckley's Chance haven't been playing for a long time. Pat's takings must be on the plummit!!
Friday, October 6, 2006Rating: rosettes

Lizbeth Dodds
 Kings War, the shore, leith
BEWARE if you book a table at the kings wark, the shore, leith as they take your booking but do not tell you that you then have to take a meal from the a la carte menu. which is double the price and half the choice! ridiculous really when you are sitting not more than 10 feet away from people who can select from the other menu.
Tuesday, September 19, 2006Rating: rosettes

chiquitin
 best pub in Leith
We used to drink in Robbies for five years. We have moved two years ago and we still miss the great atmosphere, and all the crack from Jake the boss.
Sunday, March 5, 2006Rating: rosettes

Me
 Me
This pubs raj liek , lets alot of dafties liek tyra n ashley in, disapointing liek they jis ruin it n spoil the night for every1!!
Tuesday, January 3, 2006Rating: No rosettes

sumit kumar
 i m sumit kumar&2yrs exp in 5*hotel,looking waiter
i am looking for a job as awaiter in your organization.still i m working marriott welcom group(itc hotels)new delhi,INDIA.
PLEASE GIVE ME REPLY AS SOON AS POSSIBLE.
THANKNGYOU
SUMIT KUMAR
Monday, December 5, 2005Rating: No rosettes

Richard Negus
 Great
Great beer, a charming landlord and a character that makes you feel instantly at home. Thank god that the whole of Edinburgh doesn't know about it otherwise you would never get to the bar.
Thursday, November 3, 2005Rating: rosettes

Brad
 Great staff and good banter.
Great staff and good banter.
Tuesday, October 25, 2005Rating: rosettes

Myles
 Absolutely disgusted!!
A very popular local band were informed on the day of a gig that the gig at the Harbour was cancelled due to 'a lack of beer!!!

This is one of the most badly run pubs in Edinburgh - the manager informed me that 'business was bad hence no live music!'. Treating experienced entertainers like they do it is no wonder that business is bad!!
Saturday, October 1, 2005Rating: No rosettes

J. Munro
 New Owners
Was at Bar Java recently and its looking great, just been refurbished, new bar staff and funky tunes great place to start before the town or even stay all night long will deffo be back
Monday, July 18, 2005Rating: rosettes

Martyn Whyte
 Great place to be!
Apart from the bands and the lovely location the welcome you'll receive is superb. 'Mine Host' Richard and his team bend over backwards to welcome you, oh and the beer is great too!
Buy Patch (the dog) a pickled egg and you'll have a pal for life.
Saturday, June 11, 2005Rating: rosettes

Greg Gray
 Top marks!!
One of the nicest pubs on Easter Road, with friendly local people and great staff. The guy that owns it, Jim is a great guy too!!
Thursday, May 12, 2005Rating: rosettes

Slurper
 An absolute gem
Quiet inobtrusive pub with a great selection of well kept Real Ales from all overthe UK. Service is good and a warm and friendly atmosphere is present. Tell all Real Ale appreciaters, keep out snobs and trendies!!
Monday, May 2, 2005Rating: rosettes

Anonymous
 Don't Miss This!
THE HENDERSON BROTHERS

Live & Together at the Central Bar
May 6th 9pm
Wednesday, April 20, 2005Rating: rosettes

Glenda
 Review
Fantastic pub, very welcoming and friendly. The minute you arrive, Patch the dog will give you a great welcome - remember and take some doggie treats along for him.

Check out the bands on a Friday night - they are great, especially Bedford Falls.
Monday, March 28, 2005Rating: rosettes

Patrick Vanheyst
 WANTED
My email address: patrick@vanheyst.be
Tuesday, March 15, 2005Rating: rosettes

Patrick Vanheyst
 WANTED !!!
Hi, I'm From Belgium and I found on the Internet on www.gigguide.co.uk that Friday 18 March Richie Henderson is playing in The Central Bar. I met Richie about 13 years ago and lost contact, can anyone give me his phonenumber or emailaddress, or you can give him my number or email. Phonenumber 003211455296
Thanks !!
Tuesday, March 15, 2005Rating: rosettes

Calanish
 Now reopened
The pub reopened in mid November under new ownership but with the original chef so it is more of the same.
Friday, February 11, 2005Rating: rosettes

Jemma
 The Iona Bar
You need to add the Iona Bar to your pub listings. Me and my friends work there and its a great laugh with good quiz nights, karaokes and parties.
The staff are really friendly and so are our regulars!!
Wednesday, February 9, 2005Rating: rosettes

Stuart Campbell
 WOW!!
Saw Roy Henderson playing there on Friday night. Absolutely outstanding. The new Central looks nice and there was a great atmosphere. Great bar staff.
Friday, January 28, 2005Rating: rosettes

Drinker
 Carriers Quarters
Nice quiet pub during the week and the weekend brings more drinkers which creates a nice friendly atmosphere. Reasonable pricing too.
Saturday, January 15, 2005Rating: rosettes

Yogi Rules!
 Best pub in Edinburgh
HUGHES HUGHES HUGHES HUGHES!!!
Tuesday, December 28, 2004Rating: rosettes

Oskar
 Nice one
Small but comfortable pub with a great selection of real ales and some fine whiskys.
Very quiet, and although the open fire didn´t exactly roar when we were in it was cosy anyway.
Thursday, December 16, 2004Rating: rosettes

Bruce Finlayson
 It's back and better than ever
Now refurbished and reopen. Looks great. New management and staff. Music returning - but thankfully much less folk!!
Monday, December 13, 2004Rating: rosettes

J Irvine
 Fab Venue
We hired the beer garden for a hen party and had a fabulous time. The guys couldn't have been more helpful. They were accomodating friendly and really went out of their way to help everything run smoothly!
Monday, November 29, 2004Rating: rosettes

Sarah Oram
 Best kept secret
Fantastic atmosphere, welcoming and you get to know the regulars immediately including Patch the dog!

This is a secret that has to be visited, try the live Bands on a Saturday night.

I get a bus just to go there!!! Yay!
Wednesday, November 17, 2004Rating: rosettes

Dougie Mathers
 Bye Bye!
Used to be a great pub with great music - especially fridays and saturdays. But the taxman got 'em!
very sad.
Thursday, August 26, 2004Rating: No rosettes

stuart
 excellent food
Excellent seafood, from sandwiches to soup to full meals.
Cosy open fires in winter, bright and sunny in the summer.
Monday, August 9, 2004Rating: rosettes

Archie Thrush-Davidson
 Ashes to ashes! Burnt doon!
Ah well, done to a cinder - not the lamb Davy had on in the kitchen, but the pub in entirety!

Burnt doon! The landlord's ego was saved though!
Friday, May 14, 2004Rating: rosettes


Tuesday, December 12, 2017
YOU ARE IN
EDINBURGH

Whats On

List FEATURED Pubs



FEATURE SEARCH
Real Ale
Guest Ales
Wine Selection
Restaurant
Bar Food
Country Pubs
Town/City Pubs
Scenic Pubs
Student Pubs
Quiet Pubs
Accommodation
Function Room
Open Fire Pubs
Wooden Beams
Games Room
Beer Garden
Kids Welcome
Wheelchair Access
Pets Welcome
WI-FI Access
SKY Sports TV


View the Comments



Copyright © 1999 - 2013 www.bestpubs.co.uk ltd V2.1.19