www.bestpubs.co.uk
 



Home 
Our Blog 
Search Whats On 
Search For Pubs 

------JOIN BESTPUBS------- 
Landlords 
Contributors 
Advertise 

-----SWITCH AREA TO------
Edinburgh 
East End 
Leith/Northside 
New Town 
Old Town 
Outlying 
Southside 
West End 
Midlothian 
Perth/Kinross/Fife 
Scottish Borders 
Stirling/Clackmannan 
West Lothian 

Search Other Areas 

--------SHORT CUTS--------- 
Contact Bestpubs 
Pub Books 
Cookies 


 Selected Comments in New Town

Colin T. Elder
 Sad memory still of what had been a lovely time !
Perhaps 2004 or thereabouts, which can be verified by the management as the following incident was related the following day by a hand-delivered letter, the following experience happened. I had entered this establishment around 2.30p.m. one day, and perhaps was only one of no more than a handful of other customers. I was greeted by a young bar-tender and had a pint of Guinness, as I remember, sitting at the bar enjoying conversation with the bar-tender. Having left my mother literally across the other side of the street at Jamaica Mews, I left as my intention was to ascertain whether I felt I would like to take my mother across to the bar, who is a lady who has just turned ninety-five years old. Five to ten minutes later my mother and I entered and sat away from the bar enjoying each other's company, and our craic. By around five o'clockish the bar became busier, particuliar as it was nearing the end of some business employees working day. My mother and I had several drinks in an ordered and even fashion and a table to our right became occupied by three, perhaps four respectable younger ladies. After they had sat there for fifteen or twenty minutes or so as they were on my immediate right-hand side I happened to make a civil comment to which they responded happily and another by me to which there was laughter. That was the end of any exchange. I was there to be there with my mother, and had no need of any other company, being always open to persons entering ours should it happen, with grace. When I next went to the bar to order another drink for ourselves, a new bar-tender who had come on duty around five o'clock after serving, said ' could I stay in my own company '. I was bewildered by this but made no mention of it to my mother. Around six thirty time my mother required to go to the toilet, and I escorted her there as there were stairs to it and she did not know where to go anyway. I waited in that ante-room and eventually perched myself on the cushioned window-sill patiently waiting for my mother. Two young gentlemen who were enjoying their conversation after a few moments acknowledged the fact that I was there, so we exchanged pleasantries, and fell silent. Whilst still waiting for my mother the bar-tender appeared at this section and removed some empty glasses and said, ' I thought I said to stay in your own company ', to which I made no response, as he walked away. I escorted my mother back to our seats. A few minutes later I returned to the bar and ordered, and was served. Eventually I returned to the bar once again and was told ' I was not being served '. On my return I discreetly mentioned to my mother, in time, what the situation was, and so eventually we left.

This type of behaviour should never be acceptable. What issue the bar-tender had I do not know I did not ask him. All I should like to end this tale is by saying I am not in the habit of being asked to leave a licensed premises. Indeed I have been known to be encouraged to stay by an establishment's ambience.

I have never returned to this bar !

In every tale there is a story, I trust you never have to tell yours.
Tuesday, June 20, 2017Rating: rosettes

New owner
 New Ownership
Hello fellow pub-lovers,
I just wanted you to know that Dirty Dick's is under new ownership, so please not to judge us by previous comments! Fresh fresh food and very carefully kept ales. We'd also love to think our staff are happy and well looked after.
Saturday, June 18, 2016Rating: rosettes

Eric
 
What is this latest trend in Edinburgh pubs all about? Every pub you go into now in the afternoon has reserved signs from a certain time on the tables. Since when could you reserve a table in a pub? Or is this the staff keeping tables for regulars and friends?
Friday, April 1, 2016Rating: No rosettes

Marguerita Bryan
 Best fish and chip sharing platter
Last Friday my daughter and I made a day trip to Edinburgh to meet up with my sister in law from Livingston.
After walking the Royal Mile we decided to have lunch before hitting the shops, so we all had a Tennants lager to quench our thirst and decided to share the fish and chip platter.
Delicious choice - white fish (I hate any shade of grey fish) scampi, sausage bites, onion rings and chips. Served with small bowls of ketchup, mayo, mushy peas and tartare sauce.
Pleased I didn't read any reviews before heading up there.
Thursday, December 4, 2014Rating: rosettes

Jangus
 Great bar
What a great place, if you want to be cool, this is not the bar for you.. if you want to party, this is definitely the place for you. the piano man plays all the songs you want to sing and dance too at the top of your voice, like pianoman, don't stop believing, hey jude etc.. drinks are pricey as it is a late night, live entertainment venue, open til 3am..
entrance is free, and the doorman are some of the most accommodating in the city.. if you like rock'n'roll high energy piano entertainment.. its the bar for you!

fingers has been around for over 25years and has a faithful and loyal customer base.. people from all walks of life, working class, upper class, students. the typical customer is the kind of person who doesn't notice 'how sticky the floor is', especially when their hands are in the air and having the time of their life. people don't come to fingers to find themselves, they come to loose themselves!!

well worth trying out.. gets busy from midnight onwards..
Friday, October 24, 2014Rating: rosettes

Diane Beaton
 
Are you still in business?
Enjoyed the Steak & Kidney pie at the Ivanhoe in 2000.
Friday, June 28, 2013Rating: No rosettes

Craig Waites
 Not Impressed
The sign outside says biggest & best fish & chips. Imagine my dissapointment when I was served grey fish. Not Cod or Haddock but a totally tasteless fish that I could not even identify & not would I want to. Tourists must wonder what all the fuss is about if this is what they are served.
Wednesday, January 9, 2013Rating: No rosettes

James Grey
 My Local
The one true Rock pub in Edinburgh. Stevie the Landlord is a cool cat and the Jukebox is a legend. I'm often there on a saturday night and it's a great craic! Well recomended.
Monday, October 8, 2012Rating: rosettes

Graham Hannaford Devon
 Loved it Large
Loved it me and my partner spent all evening chatting to the laddie behind the bar he even bought my partner Leon a drink and showed him some tricks with handcuffs.
Thursday, July 19, 2012Rating: rosettes

Helen
 Toilet Problems
Ladies toilets still not working?

Was directed to use the Gents

But as there was no lock on the door turned the offer down.
and felt very uncomfortable and had a stomach ache as i was on my period. not good emough.
Thursday, June 14, 2012Rating: No rosettes

Nathan
 Let Down
Only about three people in the pub so did not bother staying.
Thursday, May 31, 2012Rating: No rosettes

Rowan
 Food made me ill
Sorry but nice pub and service but I ate there last night 08.03.2012 and had bangers and mash and it made me very ill.

The sausages were reheated and gave me a very upset stomach.This was my experience.
Friday, March 9, 2012Rating: No rosettes

lynette park
 
Went in..nice bar...but staff unfriendly and impolite...been twice...won't go again.
Thursday, February 2, 2012Rating: rosettes

Brian Denoon
 Names of Poets
It must be well over a decade ago that I first drew attention to the management that the names of Norman MacCaig and Hugh MacDiarmid are misspelled on the elaborate notice you have outside your entrance. Nothing was done about it, nor on a subsequent occasion I drew attention to it. It really looks bad in our Capital City and does your business no favours..
Thursday, December 8, 2011Rating: No rosettes

Paul F Cockburn
 Spell-checker
Given the fuss they make of the bar's literary history, you'd think they'd at least spell Hugh MacDiarmid's and Norman MacCaig's names correctly on the signage. Clearly don't care that much about literature, as long as it helps bring in the punters.
Wednesday, December 7, 2011Rating: rosettes

Fras
 Can agree enough
Further to the comments left by previous patron. I am still at a loss to work out how you go from asking dog to shut up to being a gay basher!!!
Maybe the dog owners need to be more In tune with there dog than there sexuality?

It is people like that.that give the gay Comunity a bad name
Monday, November 7, 2011Rating: rosettes

Ed Coxon
 Yapping dog owned by irksome Gay man???
The comments made by the gentleman about his young yapping dog are curious to daft - where is the correlation between the patrons dissatisfaction about having to remove a noisy dog (a totally reasonable request) and the suggestion/allegation that the bar tender has shown disquiet at the customer's sexual orientation??? A preposterous notion with no foundation whatsoever - idiotic and self indulgent oversensitive clap trap - Kay's is an excellent establishment and continues to this day even after 25 years of patronage!!
Sunday, November 6, 2011Rating: rosettes

Lee
 Pets not welcome!
Having visited Kays for many years with and without a dog; I was recently asked to leave because my dog made a noise!!!! Said dog was being petted by STAFF and other patrons and being young is apt to yap and play when petted - to be asked by staff to leave because he made a noise after staff had been causing him to be playful rather begs belief... (it was an un-recognised barman, who seemed none too keen on having gay men in the pub.....)

My house overlooks Kays and I've always been tolerant of the odd noisey episode, but in future I will note and report every episode of antisocial behaviour to the relevant authorities.

A sad decline in a once grand local institution.
Friday, September 23, 2011Rating: No rosettes

Martina Kilgarriff
 Cold Food
Four of us called into this pub for a drink and the menu looked very tempting so we decided to order. 2 of us complained about the food being cold, we were ignored and no attempt was made to rectify the situation. Wouldnt reccomend as there are plenty of other eateries in the vacinity. Wouldnt go back!!
Monday, August 29, 2011Rating: rosettes

kylie
 
I visited this bar a while back and was disgusted that my Jack Daniels & cole was only half full, when i asked if I could have a full glass which Im sure I paid for, I was asked for an extra pound. i visited again on the weekend forgetting my first experience & was dissapointed the problem still existed. the bar is great unfortunately the staff are somewhat judgmental or their customers & seem to take a liking to only those who have common interests or similar to themselves in their quirky personalaties....I would sugest to take a look at the bar then leave
Monday, July 18, 2011Rating: No rosettes

Princess Ash
 Biggest Dive in Rose Street
This pub is probably the worst in Rose Street. No food, bunch of old guys who's language can only be described as 'choice'. Badly managed by some woman who has no evident skills. Not recommended!
Wednesday, July 13, 2011Rating: No rosettes

Rob
 Why bother?
The only plus I can think of is the small beer garden at the rear. Otherwise the surly barman and indifferent service make it a place to avoid with so many other attractive options nearby.
Wednesday, June 22, 2011Rating: rosettes

Tom M.
 Dreadful
I'm not joking...
Saturday, June 4, 2011Rating: No rosettes

Raymond
 they are dicks!
They are all dicks over there. Suck my dick who own this place. I have worked there like a fool to be fired because i was trying to serve a pint to a scottish customer.
Dirty dicks, yes they are!!!
Sunday, May 8, 2011Rating: No rosettes

kevin and paula
 crap
ordered 2 meals got the 55 mins later nice but not worth the wait oh aye and not to mention £8.30 for 2 bottles of koppaberg.
Sunday, May 1, 2011Rating: rosettes

James Beacoup
 Pure mental!
Aye this place is mental like! Full of radgey gadgeys steaming aboot tryin' to find the bog...nutters eh!? Staff are mental too ken...pure swagger awai!
Tuesday, March 15, 2011Rating: rosettes

Kate Thomson
 
4 of us had lunch today in your pub and the food was poor and so was the service. The bar was unattended and we waited some time to be served both at the bar and the table. 3 of us ate salmon with noodles and it was very dry and tastless. We had visited twice before and on these occasions found our food and service excellent. Very disappointing today especially as we had brought friends with us.
Tuesday, August 31, 2010Rating: rosettes

Elizabeth Gordon
 
Spent a few hours in this pub on Monday 9th August 2010. Joanne behind the bar is very friendly and a great wee bar person. We were made to feel welcome and had a good bit of banter with the locals. Would recommend this pub to everybody it has great atmosphere great prices and we will definately visit when we come back to Edinburgh.
From the three Paisley buddies thank you for a great afternoon.
Tuesday, August 10, 2010Rating: rosettes

Tom Fisch
 
I was extemely lucky to find this pub early in my 3 years of working in Scotland. It is my favorite pub with excellent pints, drams, and food. The staff made me feel welcome and at home from the start of my early visits to Edinburgh. Just wonderful folks and atmosphere.
Friday, July 30, 2010Rating: rosettes

chris
 Middle-aged men refused service
I’m holidaying in the UK from Australia and was refused service by the unfriendly Manager because my 34 year old Asian friend was not carrying any identification. We have visited pubs all over the UK and this is the only place that has been a problem. I wonder why. My complaint was brushed aside. They refused to tell me the last time they’d asked a 34 year old Caucasian for his identification. The company said “Under the current laws the person responsible for running any bar is permitted to refuse service for any number of reasons ... a reason does not have to be given.” Left a very sour taste in our mouths and spoiled our visit to Edinburgh.
Thursday, July 29, 2010Rating: No rosettes

Russell Fontaine
 Visit to Scotland
I visited the pub while I was in Edinburgh for the British open. We stayed near there, and found this place walking back from Waverly station. We went there once every night. I loved the atmosphere, and the service was fantastic. I especially thought Sarah was fantastic. I am a big fan of her. However, the estabishment is fantastic, and I wish Washington DC would get a place like that. I will be back, and will let everyone know about this place.
Tuesday, July 20, 2010Rating: No rosettes

IRISH JIM
 GREAT PUB, GREAT FOOD, FRIENDLY HELPFUL STAFF
Tuesday, July 13, 2010Rating: rosettes

Alan DUckworth
 
What a great place, nothing too much trouble for the staff. Called in for a drink12/07/10 and stopped for a couple of hours
Monday, July 12, 2010Rating: No rosettes

dawn craig
 food
was in last friday and tried the new food menu,,,i was with several friends so we tried most things on the menu and we were really really satisfied,,,excellent food well done to the new chef !!
Tuesday, June 22, 2010Rating: rosettes

L. Cumming
 
Sorry, thom, but like most people here, i love this place, i go there for the decor and the cocktails mainly but i have lots of wonderful memories there and even going back to celebrate my birthday this year, and if the bar tender took offense at you asking for a top up you obviously didnt ask in the right way
Monday, June 7, 2010Rating: rosettes

Smegsby
 fine establishment
A damn fine establishment. The citrus-smelling toilets are a relief, and the romanesque interior is a sight to behold.
Monday, May 24, 2010Rating: rosettes

Peter Robinson
 Good Choice
It's only one and a half hours journey by train from Newcastle to Edinburgh and on our many visits our plans usually include a visit to this pub. We enjoy the good choice of real ales provided and the variety of food available. Lest I forget...........the prices of both are great.
Saturday, May 15, 2010Rating: rosettes

tpm
 sorry, correction.....
the cheapest beer is 3 (three) pounds,
two would have been a bargain.

yes, cheapest pint cost you 3 sterling pound here.

Avoid.
Friday, May 14, 2010Rating: No rosettes

thom
 another awful pub
A pint of cheapest lager, Foster's in this case, cost you 2 pounds. And the fat ageing Goth bartender gives you a bad pint well short of 400ml, and when you ask to to fill it up, he would take an offence, AVOID like a plague. I am telling you for your sake, from the bottom from my heart! They are Mr Hyde not the Jekylle. Avoid!!!! there are lots of decent pubs in edinburgh, not this one.
Friday, May 14, 2010Rating: No rosettes

Anonymous
 Pub Closed in 2008
Pub Closed in 2008
Wednesday, April 28, 2010Rating: No rosettes

Steven
 
Colin are you mad?
The Tap was one of THE best places in Stockbridge to go for a nice lunch/dinner. Maybe the food being served before was spoiling us a bit too much, but I know I will never eat there again. The food I was served a week ago was god awful in comparison to what it was before. Unseasoned, ugly, bland and most importantly BORING. Still a lovely place to drink, and the staff as always are fantastic, but if you're wanting something nice for your tea, head to Bells or the Blue Parrot!
Thursday, April 22, 2010Rating: rosettes

Craig Smith
 Great bar ignorant rude bar staff
Very nice bar with good layout and location. Drink in it every now and again. Never again though after last night, two of the most ignornt bar staff ever. jJust give us the pint without the dirty look ta very much.
Tuesday, March 16, 2010Rating: rosettes

Sean
 PS... Sat night 13 March!
Tuesday, March 16, 2010Rating: rosettes

Sean
 Smiliest barmaid in Edinburgh ;-)
...not to mention the relaxed atmosphere, friendly clientele and amazing chilli nuts! Sean. cahillsj@hotmail.com
Tuesday, March 16, 2010Rating: rosettes

Colin
 
Not quite the story i heard about the previous chef but in any case a new team has taken over the kitchen and the food is as good if not better. Staff are knowledgeable, friendly and welcoming. Probably the best pub in stockbridge for a pint of cask ale.
Tuesday, March 16, 2010Rating: rosettes

Peter
 A plate of goose that laid the golden egg anyone?
the kitchen at the Tap went from pies to excellent meals. But you're too late for that now folks. The Stockbridge Tap kitchen has closed as a result of the parent company wanting to double the chef's rent. A plate of goose that laid the golden egg anyone?
Wednesday, February 10, 2010Rating: rosettes

Anon
 *****Purse Theft Alert*****
HAD PURSE STOLEN ON 3RD JANUARY. Clear CCTV footage of girl in mid to late 20s, slim build, 5'7, blue or green eyes, blonde or light brown hair. Cream colured NIKE beany hat, black jacket with furry collar, grey leggings and boots. Had brown handbag and black/orange mobile phone. Scottish accent, possibly working as a pair or group. SAT ON THE END OF THE BAR IN THE SEAT NEAREST THE RIGHT HAND SIDE DOOR. LOOK OUT FOR THIS ONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Nice pub apart from that incident!!!
Tuesday, January 5, 2010Rating: rosettes

john
 Now called Iglu
Been called Iglu for a few years now
Tuesday, December 22, 2009Rating: No rosettes

john
 Been shut for a while
Been shut for a while now
Monday, December 21, 2009Rating: No rosettes

john
 Converted to a restaurant
Converted to a restaurant
Monday, December 21, 2009Rating: No rosettes

john
 Now a restaurant
BAR 38 has closed as a bar and is now a restaurant
Monday, December 21, 2009Rating: No rosettes

Mike
 The Moustache is back
Not as long as it once was but you can still put a worm on it and use 'Fritz' as a fishing lure. Great beer and I love the guest ales. It give me a chance to try a few new and often obscure ales.
Monday, September 14, 2009Rating: rosettes

Mary
 Not for girls!
Horrible place if you are a girl. Rude blonde lady manager called Karen! Men were using the woman toilet! Manager asked us to stop talking! Unbeliveable! Apparently we were just too happy! Sad place this pub is. Go to Dirty Dicks at the end of Rose Street or Black Roses Tavern opposite Auld Hundred or any other that you will have so much more fun!!!!
Tuesday, September 8, 2009Rating: No rosettes

MARGARET HAMLETT
 
COMING TO EDINBURGH FOR THE FIRST TIME I WENT TO THE ST BERNARDS AND FOUND THE PEOPLE THERE WARM FRIENDLY AND VERY WELCOMING. THE STAFF ARE ALSO THE SAME AND WILL RECOMMEND THIS TO ALL WHO VISIT STOCKBRIDGE.
Monday, August 17, 2009Rating: rosettes

Iain Hamilton
 First class bar
Excellent real ale in Edinburgh's finest bar. Friendly staff and tasty snacks and rolls. The only place to watch International Rugby if you are not lucky enough to have a ticket.
Monday, August 10, 2009Rating: rosettes

Peter MacPherson
 Truly, one of the greatest Bars in Scotland
My happiest times in were when I lived in Edinburgh, I returned to Hectors after a years abscence, and it just gets better - a truly great bar with excellant staff who have make you feel at home -Hectors, its something special....
Monday, August 10, 2009Rating: rosettes

craig
 yesterday afternoon
i fell in love with this pub,holly is the best bar maid ever .
Sunday, June 14, 2009Rating: rosettes

John W
 Chill out
Hectors is a great bar to chill out in with the best chill-out music I've heard for a long time. It has excellent coffee, good atmosphere and has Hoegaarten and Erdinger white beers on draft. The food is great - especially the Eggs Benedict which is not to be missed.
Thursday, May 21, 2009Rating: rosettes

Laura
 Very attractive place
I liked a lot the interior decoration. And the staff was very kind with me (a poor French girl who lost her wallet). I really recommand this pub.
Tuesday, April 14, 2009Rating: rosettes

ups and downs
 Good stuff
A great pub to go to for that authentic Scottish feel, great food and drink although a wee bit pricey and although the staff are generally very nice I found the owner to be quite rude.
Thursday, March 5, 2009Rating: rosettes

LN & Calum
 an honest pub
Superb atmosphere created by caring staff. Sunday breakfast is a must as is the properly homemade Burgers YUM...
The bar is always spotless.
We'd recommend this place to anybody.
Sunday, February 22, 2009Rating: rosettes

aitchjay
 superb
barmans moustache is back! friendly though well-to-do patrons from edinburghs rugby set. didn't want to leave and will definetly return
Friday, February 13, 2009Rating: rosettes

Iain Duncan
 Best Bar, Bar none
Fraser, Pints, Biltong...Happy
Wednesday, January 14, 2009Rating: rosettes

Barry Taylor
 The STANDARD
This bar is no longer anything to do with the laughing duck and has been renamed The STANDARD it is a free house and is a family owned buisness
Monday, November 24, 2008Rating: rosettes

Andrea Power
 The coolest of pubs
Dont know how any-one can fault this pub, the effort that has gone into the decor is amazing, the staff are all very friendly and attentive, the food is great value for money and i dont understand how people can complain when the prices are kept so low. Overall this pub has the best atmosphere and for my partner and myself was the best pub we visited in Edinburgh.
Saturday, September 27, 2008Rating: rosettes

George
 it's ok
very big and busy pub with a good choice of beers.we were slightly disappointed with the food this time but overall we would go back.
Saturday, September 6, 2008Rating: rosettes

Lionel Beck
 Great Eccentric Pub
We visited for one of the free comedy Fringe acts, Three Mousketeers - the acts were crap but the pub was quite the opposite!
Thursday, August 28, 2008Rating: rosettes

john
 amazing staff
went there last saturday and had an amazing night. we were supposed to go on to another bar but couldn't tear ourselves away from the two girls behind the bar...trust me get there now
Monday, August 11, 2008Rating: rosettes

kat
 Great Time
Was there on staurday night with 6 friends, what a scream we had, the staff where great and the music was cheesy fun, i have not had such a good night out in ages. Would defo go back again, and would defo say to all those reading give it a try and dont pay attention to the negative reviews on here.
Monday, August 4, 2008Rating: rosettes

Shmuel T. Meyer
 jerusalem - Israel
I remember an old man with a cap which had poured my malt whisky in my lager. thirty years ago: my youth and an extraordinary memory.
Sunday, June 29, 2008Rating: rosettes

dave f
 pool bable back!
The Vinny has returned the pool table - best news i've heard in years! Got five real ales now and even doing double deals on spirits. Remains a great wee howf in the New Town/Stokbridge
Saturday, February 17, 2007Rating: rosettes

Andrew Kane
 A real pub
A top pub. I usually visit Edinburgh a couple of times each year and always head to Kays Bar for great ale and excellent value food. Haggis neaps and tatties make me very happy!
Thursday, February 15, 2007Rating: rosettes

Steve McKenzie
 Best Bar In The World!!
Great beer, great staff,great wine & great company. Miss it like crazy.
Steve
Iraq
Monday, January 15, 2007Rating: rosettes

Neil Mitchell
 A Great Experience
A pub where you can leave the cares of the world outside and get lost in conversation with friends with a great real ale in your hand. Cozy and relaxed.
Sunday, January 14, 2007Rating: rosettes

dwb
 
Waited ages to be served as the staff were busy attending to what seemed to be regulars. The food we ordered was not as described on the menu(soup of the day with thick cut bloomer and a platter of butter)no bloomer no butter!!!
Welsh rarebit(a whole mini farmhouse loaf with a mustard dressing covered in toasted cheese and drizzled with worcester sauce)in reality was on a quarter slice of panini bread.
The Manager? just sniggered and made us feel uncomfortable for pointing this out, and the chef? passed our table 3 times to glare at us for having the ordasity to question the menu.
Not recommended if you want to feel welcome give it a miss.
Sunday, January 7, 2007Rating: No rosettes

St Vincent
 
A fairly large pub with double frontage halfway along Rose St. Whilst it is not exactly anti-English is doesn't seem too tourist friendly. Local rumours tell of the attempted murder of an English bank manager here some years ago when it was called The Goblet. Perhaps he turned someone down for a loan.

In one corner of the bar you will find a small window seat next to which you can see where a telephone was once located. In the days before mobile phones this was colloquially known as I'll be home late corner.
Wednesday, January 3, 2007Rating: rosettes

Geordie
 Grim
Standard city centre T & J Bernard dive, bad beer, dirty, smells of wee, lousy food and no atmosphere - head for Thistle Street or the Guildford/Cafe Royal and give this one a miss.
Thursday, December 7, 2006Rating: rosettes

Gary Oldman
 Nice pub man
This pub is magic for watching the footie in. Sky TV and Setanta Sports. All live games on Big Plasma's and a nice log fire with great beers! The talent is also good. What more does a man need ?
Monday, December 4, 2006Rating: rosettes

Todd Law
 past its best
Me and my friends used to visit this bar regularly and it was a great bar. However, recently it has steadily gone downhill. The toilets are disgusting and the gents are always flooded. The ketchup is left on the tables well after food has stopped being served. On my most recent visit the beer served was out of date and the fridge was not working thus the beer was therefore warm. There was no apology from the bar staff. Milnes would be a fantastic pub if refurbished, cleaned and managed properly.
Sunday, November 26, 2006Rating: rosettes

Glen Blaikie
 Updated and now called Bar Twist
I have to say that i was a regular of the Newtown Bar before the recent make over and thankully I am still a regular.

Gone is the traditional look and in comes a much more contemporary feel to the place. Good food on at lunchtimes which is a bonus and not city centre prices either!

Yes it is still predominantly a more mature gay mans bar but woman are often found in the place and adding to the great atmosphere.

Well done guys for updating the bar
Friday, November 17, 2006Rating: rosettes

Linda King
 HAMILTONS BAR STOCKBRIDGE
myself and my two friends had a great lunch on Saturday 4th November staff were lovely and couldn't do enough for us think it has two new managers who took over at start of week, we are booked for our xmas lunch.highy recommend.
Wednesday, November 8, 2006Rating: rosettes

David A
 Best Real Ale in Stockbridge/Newtown!
A mate and I popped in to this brilliant wee boozer last night to take in the champions league football with a few real ales. The ale was of the highest quality and the bar staff were also really helpful and knowledgable. Equally as good was the four screens on offer, two showing the Celtic game and two showing the Man U game. Definitely a great bar for lovers of beer and sport and will definitely return to try their food menu during the day which the locals assured me is excellent!
Wednesday, October 18, 2006Rating: rosettes

John sykes
 Le chien pecans
The pub has a very old feel about it. The variety of ale etc is very good, My only criticism is that here never seems to be enough staff to man the bar.
Warm and pleasant atmosphere.
Friday, October 13, 2006Rating: rosettes

Chris
 Bar manager no longer has a funny looking mustache
Though I've never actually been there
Friday, October 13, 2006Rating: rosettes

Anonymous
 Nice to visit but dodgy to work
I am another in the growing list of staff that has left this establishment unhappy. The place is run purely for profit with no thought for the staff. I have been shortchanged on many occasions and never more so with tips, the staff who deserve them see barely a fraction of what they take. The only thing that made it bareable was the staff who somehow put up with the crap and make it fun still.
Good eating! (this isnt a real pub)
Thursday, October 5, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Tom Howald
 Best Angus Steak at a good price!
During my seven days stay in Scotland
this is the place where I had the best
Aberdeen Angus steak. The ale was a bit too warm for my taste though.
Sunday, September 24, 2006Rating: rosettes

previous worked there
 What a joke
This would have to be one of the worst bars to spend your money at. The beer is off, or quite literally off - they allways run out.. funny considering how quite they are. The Manager doesn't have a clue. I worked here thinking this place was something else, only to find out that it was a laughing stock... Only worked there for a few months but in those months along nearlly every staff member has left and the beer.... well it is really expensive and still OFF.
Wednesday, September 13, 2006Rating: No rosettes

James Guyatt
 Pretty ok
A group of us go to Edinburgh once or twice a year and we always end up in here. It's not the most spacious but the staff are friendly and i like the little paper beer mat they put under every single drink you buy! Oh and the buckets of free matches are great to stick in your wallet if you ever get caught without a lighter (even though i doubt they have them anymore with the no smoking everywhere)
Tuesday, September 5, 2006Rating: rosettes

Fraser White
 Bonza
Hi my name is fraser, and I really like going to pubs that are a long way from my house. Especially when I have my bike
Wednesday, August 30, 2006Rating: rosettes

John McGregor
 Great pub, great ale
Was drinking in this place recently and it made an excellent impression. The real ale is probably the best I've had in Edinburgh, especially the Deuchars. The place is well kept and the staff were all extremely friendly. Ten out of ten.
Tuesday, August 29, 2006Rating: rosettes

Tom Johnson
 Spot on pub (ignore negative comments)
This pub is fantastic, it has a great atmosphear and a good place for a laugh, on stag nights or partys. However when going to the toilet dont forget to take a book with you!!!
Monday, August 21, 2006Rating: rosettes

Nick Fawcett
 Loved it
It was years ago that I visited Edinburgh - but I still talk about this pub. Living in South Africa, I miss all the decent cask beers. Brett Riverboat is obviously not all there. If he doesn't like the size of the place - don't go there. I would kill for another visit!!
Friday, August 4, 2006Rating: rosettes

brian brand
 superb
i am the comment above this is my rating definatley a 5+
Wednesday, July 26, 2006Rating: rosettes

brian brand
 looking for some feed back
hi i went i saw i checked it out i listened the beer was perfect , very friendly atmosphere ,accomodating, but i i was alone and shy so i did'nt play on any of the mic nights. here's your chance to hear me and any visitors check this out http://www.tagworld.com/azuka
Wednesday, July 26, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Sandra
 This is the greatest pub EVER
I love all Hogshead pubs. They have such a great atmosphere and I always feel really safe in them. The clientel is also delightful, not at all threatening. They have a great selection of beers too. Carling, Carslberg and Tennants. My boyfriend Tony loves it too.
Tuesday, July 11, 2006Rating: rosettes

Andrew Moran
 Best entertainment in Edinburgh
Dunno who the the supposed miming piano player was, and I am a very 30 something who never has trouble getting in. The beer is pricey but the weekend crowd enjoying a singalong to the likes of Cass (does he still play? - He's over 60) or whoever playing the tunes is just about a good an atmosphere as you can get.
Friday, July 7, 2006Rating: rosettes

KW
 cool pub
as an edinburgh resident and local drinker, i can safely say this is one of the best pubs i've been to. friendly staff, great atmosphere and great cocktails (try ENVY its delicious!) - what more could a girl want!
Thursday, June 29, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Dudebhoy
 The Best Wee Boozer in Edinburgh
Fantastic small pub in edinburgh, at least 6 guest ales, plus IPA onsite. Try and go there to have a good pint from either Atlas or Harviestoun's and you're in for a good time. Excellent bar staff, shame about the tv on blink during last 10 mins of sweden v T&T ha ha.
Monday, June 19, 2006Rating: rosettes

denis mcnelly
 great pub with real ale
i think the other guy is wrong
Tuesday, June 6, 2006Rating: rosettes

MS
 Good pub with great folk.
This a really good 'proper' pub tucked down in the basement on bohemian St Stephen Street in Stockbridge. Probably the best pub in Edinburgh for an informal (turn up and play) folk session (Every Thursday night 9 to midnightish). Highly recommended!

If only Edinburgh had more 'real' pubs like this and less 'style bar' poser palaces with sky high prices and unauthentic 'theme' pubs with conversation killing loud music, wall to wall stag and hen parties and bog standard global brand beers! If that's your bag then stick to George Street, Rose Street, Grassmarket and Lothian Road, but if not take a stroll down to Stockbridge for a more pleasant alternative.

If you enjoy a friendly, attractive, authentic pub with decent beer and great music the Antiquary might just become your favourite pub in Edinburgh too!
Sunday, May 28, 2006Rating: rosettes

Maggie Porter, St Stephen St
 Great food, great drink, great sevice!
I'm really surprised to read the review by 'anonymous' because I was at Hamiltons last night and had a very good meal! My friends that were with me hadn't been before and were very impressed also! The food was of the highest quality and I certainly didnt need to go anywhere to eat afterwards, in fact I stayed and drank in the bar until closing time! wonderful!
Monday, May 8, 2006Rating: rosettes

Emilie Wilson
 Bad staff gone!
Following my bad experience with the duty manager (see below), I wrote to the manager to complain. I immediately got a letter back from him saying that that duty manager had left - a good thing! Also, he would talk to the other staff to make it didn't happen again. And as an apology for the experience, he even offered me a complimentary meal for two and a bottle of wine
:-). I think I'll redeem it, despite Anonymous' terrible indictment of the food.
Monday, May 8, 2006Rating: rosettes

Anonymous
 Absolute Rubbish
Hi,

I dont normally write reviews about anything that I feel is poor or good about restaurants...However, Hamiltons was the only expection - as it was really poor to the point of embaressment. We have a meal for six and the food was cold and of poor quantity and quality. The beer also tasted off. Dont go here its a rip off. We paid, we left...had to go somewhere else to fill our stomachs.
Monday, May 8, 2006Rating: No rosettes

allan
 worth a visit
we visit edinburgh about 3 times a year and always end up in this pub. excellent choice of ever changing beers and friendly staff who actually smile at the customer. totally recommend.
Monday, May 1, 2006Rating: rosettes

David Sands
 Fantastic Experience!
I went to Hamiltons for the first time this weekend and had a great time! the staff were friendly and efficient and the atmosphere was buzzing! My meal was well above my expectations and I would recommend this bar/restaurant to anyone!
Monday, May 1, 2006Rating: rosettes

Emilie Wilson
 Lovely setting, shame about the staff
I've been a regular at Hammies for years, both eating and drinking, and had, until last night, always enjoyed my experience there. Last night, I was having a quiet pint with some friend just before closing, when the 'so-called' manager suddenly started laying into us for not finishing up our drinks. It was only 25 minutes after last orders, but he just got really agressive, told us to leave now and said he would be happy if we never came back again! Well, no worries about that, mate!
Thursday, April 27, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Hank Roberts
 Hank
Arriving in edinburgh after a long journey from the USA we came upon this quant bar in Rose Street, I have to say we all had very good experiance the food was excellent and the staff extremly helpful. I have to say a big thank you to Lisa who made our experiance very enjoyable.
Sunday, April 23, 2006Rating: rosettes

sa
 Pish
the kenilworth has 2 be the worst pub in edinburgh DO NOT GO THERE
Thursday, April 20, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Richard
 what a great pub!
Dear sirs,
After a particularly enjoyable experience in the U.K we feel we must comment on the exeptional service we received in Milnes Bar. the food was enjoyable but the staff made our visit all the more special, We did not expect to recieve such good service in a pub atmosphere. Thanks very much for getting the information about the bus tours, we didn't expect it!!!!
From a happy customer.
Tuesday, April 18, 2006Rating: rosettes

Chris
 re Kenny 10/03/06
As the duty manager on that occasion, I feel these circumstances were outwith my control. I understand it was not ideal, but to cut that particular speaker off would have resulted in the entire pub being silenced. I tried to help by suggesting you move to another table which was readily availible. The lanuage which followed was offensive and unjustified. I feel it is unfair to judge an entire pub on the basis of one speaker breaking down. The other customers on that occasion (even the ones at the next table) commented that they had a very enjoyable experience and didn't ask for a full refund on all their drinks that night. I hope that the opinion of of one abusive customer will not influence the bar as a whole. Anyone that's been here regularly will know that this is a pub that people will return to.
Tuesday, April 18, 2006Rating: rosettes

Mike
 No Longer Exists
Hasnt been called Aubreys for about 3 years. Changed to some kind of style bar and restuarant. Aubrey who was a great barman and cool dude moved to Uganda to run a lodge.
Sunday, April 16, 2006Rating: No rosettes

elainemarie
 Full of posing hairdressers
Great laugh to go to this bar to people watch...if watching posers is your thing! The music is way too loud and despeite asking for it to be turned down it remnained at a ridiculous volume.
Friday, April 14, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Elainemarie
 Seen better days
Now that it's smoke free the underlying smells may overwhelm you - especially the BO from the bar staff! The ladies toilets had no loo roll and the whole place looks dirty. Very much in need of redecoration. Will not rush back.
Friday, April 14, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Jacobite
 Impressive
On my last visit to this pub I was very impressed with the extremely convivial atmosphere, the selection of meals and the available beers. The bars staff were both friendly and helpful. Definitely worth a visit for anyone doing the pubs of Edinburgh
Thursday, April 6, 2006Rating: rosettes

Colin Wood
 Great
Great pub, I loved the atmoshere the staff, and the menu. I was there in 2000 and will co back next time I am in Edinburgh.
Thursday, March 30, 2006Rating: rosettes

Bob
 Dave
Dave visited Ivanhoe on several occasions and never got served?? Either he was underage or didn't knwo he had to go to the bar. Busy places are a good sign that things are being done well. Slow places are where you will find Dave. Top pub!!!!
Friday, March 17, 2006Rating: rosettes

David Watts
 a grand boozer
this pub has very knowledgable staff with great beer and a great selection of products. Pub kept very clean and food exceptional.
Friday, March 17, 2006Rating: rosettes

Michael Grant
 A prince amongst pubs.
Real ale - good malt - good food -best pub in Scotland
Wednesday, March 15, 2006Rating: rosettes

kenny
 terrible music system and management attitude
the speakers cut in and out every few minutes, making conversation irritating. I complained to the manager whose attitude was 'it's a technical fault, move seats'.

I won't return and will advise my friends and colleagues of this attitude.

ps. the pub was empty at 11.30 pm on a Friday. No wonder
Friday, March 10, 2006Rating: No rosettes

Dionne
 The Best
This Bar is the best pub along Rose Stree by far. Freindly staff and nice crowd !!!
Friday, February 24, 2006Rating: rosettes

Donnie
 Make that the 10th Feb!
Sorry. Still hungover. Friday 10th Feb.
Sunday, February 5, 2006Rating: rosettes

Donnie
 Jamie's Leaving Do
The boy's a leg-end. He's going to Calgary to be a ski-bum or something. We're having a send off on the 7th feb. Let's get him Fingered!
Sunday, February 5, 2006Rating: rosettes

Anonymous
 Class Act
A fantstic place with well kept ales in abundances and toasties to die for - really must be more adventurous with my food order next time but the toasties are ust TOO nice - especially with several pints of summer lightning. YUMMMMY !!!!!
Thursday, January 19, 2006Rating: rosettes

fat fraz
 Its called Fingers. Make your own mind up
When I tell my friends in London that I go to a pub (regularly) called Fingers, they assume I've turned into a sex pest. When I explain in detail the nature of the beast, they are convinced I've turned into the worst kind of sex pest. One who prays on not only the drunk and the bored, but the ugly. My friend who actually is Jamie Somerville has been seen doing the burping worm breakdance (his very own) in here, and I've been lying on the piano singing at the top of my voice. There isn't much gets you kicked out of here..... Its a place to watch and be watched, as long as you realise everyone's laughing.....
Wednesday, January 18, 2006Rating: rosettes

rob Darbyshire
 A true Scottish welcome!
Staff really friendly, beer excellent!
Wonderful fellow guests....particularly beautiful yound lady in wheelchair...........stunning afternoon.....Thank you!
Sunday, January 15, 2006Rating: rosettes

rab smith
 small pub
Totally disagree with the last comment and would not venture tto the pub again. Food is expensive for what you get and is typical frozen food . Pub in whole is not clean and could do with a clean out. Bar staff are friendly but thats the only thing going for it.
Thursday, January 12, 2006Rating: rosettes

georgie boy
 great pub
really great pub in amongst some expensive tourist traps , great beer too and staff are friendly , and they sell boddies!! woohoo
Saturday, January 7, 2006Rating: rosettes

CJ
 Great place to unwind
I spent some wonderful nights here sipping cider by the fire and writing letters. I loved this place when I lived in Edinburgh. Sometimes I wish I could walk out of my flat and pop in for a couple of pints. Unfortunately, that would now require a long plane ride...
Tuesday, December 20, 2005Rating: rosettes

CJ
 Post-work hangout
I used to drink in this bar about 5 times a week when I worked in Ediburgh. Many jolly nights were spent here with co-workers.

A good place to unwind and the food was cheap.

Ivan Hoe!!
Tuesday, December 20, 2005Rating: rosettes

david alexander
 verry good pub
good pub with exelent staff
Sunday, December 4, 2005Rating: rosettes

Adrian R Jones
 Great place!
I was in Edinburgh with my partner for the Tattoo and went to the Bad Ass and I thought the food, staff, surroundings and atmosphere were great!
Monday, November 21, 2005Rating: rosettes

gill nelson
 excellent
friendly staff and a brilliant atmosphere. the toilets behind the bookcase are funny, the cocktails are yummy too.
Friday, November 18, 2005Rating: rosettes

Kenny reid
 Great bar in the centre of edinburgh
Great bar just opposite the Scott monument in the center of Edinburgh. Food and beer are great, very reasonable prices and staff very friendly. Usually some sort deal on whether for wine, other drinks or food.
Friday, October 28, 2005Rating: rosettes

JP
 
Very attractive, friendly staff. Pleasure to socialise there. Would visit again any time.
Tuesday, October 25, 2005Rating: rosettes

Melanie
 One of a kind
I have visited Dirty Dicks regularly over the past 2 years & have always found it to be first class. The food is lovley, the decor & atmosphere is extremely unique. It never lets me down!
Monday, October 10, 2005Rating: rosettes

Lee Kearney
 Legendary
I like the HH in Edinburgh. The Strongbow they serve is great and you can buy Lamberts in the cigarette machine. What more can you ask for?
Friday, October 7, 2005Rating: rosettes

gary mckenzie
 losing it
been a regular dinner at dirty dicks but latley the standard of service has dropped, influx of forgein labour, try not to speak in a scottish accent as they cant understand you. my partner orderd baked tattie with trout the potato(tattie) was rock hard, we returned it only to be told all the tatties were hard and not cooked, time 7pm! a chef that cant bake a tattie i ask you! we asked for the dish back minus the tatie only to be given salmon in the confusion, we couldnt complain a second time as we had already caused a fuss and felt intimidated with the chef and waiters glancing at us and left the meal, staff tried to be as helpfull as poss but not going back
Friday, October 7, 2005Rating: rosettes

George Bartholomew
 Excellent
On the night that i went to the Bad Ass both the food and staff were top notch. Staff didnt get anything wrong and even made sure we enjoyed our meal. I would defo go back!
Thursday, October 6, 2005Rating: rosettes

JR
 Edinburgh's Best Pub
You couldn't ask for a better pub to have a pint. Hands down the best pub that we visited in Scotland. Cheers.
Tuesday, September 13, 2005Rating: rosettes

Dougal
 Cool!
The best bar in the world! nice folk and even better beer, best looking staff in Edinburgh! ;)
Friday, September 9, 2005Rating: rosettes

Paula Badger BSc(Hons)
 Dining experience in quaint pub with atmosphere.
I took American guests there and now as a concierge/tour guide I am recommending it again. The place is reached via the back of Jury's Inn and not recommended passage at night time. Taxis do take you to this place safely. It has an atmosphere that is accentric, and fun, and the food is good. Staff were delightful in seeing to my guests needs. What is written can be said of most transient workers conditions. I recommend getting there early in the evening and taking a taxi back to your hotel.
Thursday, September 8, 2005Rating: rosettes

Nick Stewart
 FIngers Is Evil
My friend looks a lot like Jimmy Somerville and he goes to Fingers on a regular basis to pull bored Australians. Pretty much sums it up really.
Friday, September 2, 2005Rating: rosettes

Kerry Doll and Deb
 Those were the days
It was a pleasure to work there with Kirsty, Jimmy, Lexy and the rest. We had many a fab night with the regulars, Tim, Dudley, Al ,Jim the florist and all the others.
Thursday, September 1, 2005Rating: rosettes

Linda Green
 It's a real pub!
The Cat and Bagpipes (now named The Rose and Crown) is a gorgeous wee pub hidden away at the west end of Rose St. With extremely friendly and helpful staff, good quality scottish scran (food!) and live music every week, I would definately recommend making the effort.

The locals who are regulars have obviously known each other for years and seem to choose the Rose and Crown for it's authenticity of being a 'real' pub, where the attraction is lager, ale, whiskies and good ol' banter between friends!
Thursday, September 1, 2005Rating: rosettes

jason
 push the bookshelf
whaaaaat! the staff were as friendly as could be,highly recomended bar, maybe the troublemakers among you should stay away....mwaa ha haaa
Wednesday, August 31, 2005Rating: rosettes

Liam Peterson
 our visit
We have just visited the burgh and where very disapointed we used to drink there when it was finlays and had a bit of an apmosphere about it.you could get cheap drink and have a laugh on the karaoke.
Saturday, August 20, 2005Rating: No rosettes

Angelcake
 BEST PUB FOOD IN EDINBURGH!!!!!
The Bailie does by far the best pub food in Edinburgh. I'd recommend the lamb cutlets and the cumberland ring with haggis and smokey bacon YUM!!!
Monday, August 15, 2005Rating: rosettes

Shug Boabby
 Very Dodgy and Fake Performances
This bar has a very good good reputation for live music, but upon closer inspection of one of the performers last week I noticed something funny... he was miming the piano! if it's good live music you want, try the Jazz club or Whistle Binkies in old town.

There are always fights at the end of the end and sometimes in the middle, please avoid if you are in any way self respecting!

After several visits I have decided I shall not be returning.
Saturday, July 30, 2005Rating: No rosettes

Peter Backhouse
 a terrific place
i have been travelling to edinburgh from Western Australia for some 28 years and have visted heaps of pubs with my mate from Clermiston, but Dome has to be one of the most impressive places i have had the pleasure to take a drink. What a superb way to transform a bank.
Monday, July 18, 2005Rating: rosettes

Ally & Kev
 good food
soup & baguette deal is a winner any day of the week!
Thursday, July 14, 2005Rating: rosettes

Duncan
 Clean and basic
This hotel was basic, the pub scruffy and if you dont mind music till 1am it was fine. But we were charged £60 for a double room without toilet which in my opinion was way too much. £40 would have been more like it. But then its not just here that charge steep prices, the whole of Scottish/ British tourism need a good shake up. I'm currently looking at 2 star hotels in South of France for £50 toilet ensuite. Braeburn is a no star hotel. Oh and I am still waiting for the hotel to send on to me an item I left behind
Thursday, July 14, 2005Rating: rosettes

Dan
 Fantastic night had by all
50 of us managed to get into the pub and corner the poor guitarist. He played all night long and the atmosphere was incredible.

Thanks to the guitarist (sorry, can't remember his name) and thanks to the pub for letting us all in.

Also, I'd like to thank the pub for refusing to serve me alcohol the previous night - on account of me being too smashed. Despite my protests, you were right, I was wrong.


I really recommend this pub. Highlight of my weekend.
Friday, June 17, 2005Rating: rosettes

Kyle Phoenix
 closed down
was a nice bar, but never busy hence its closure a while back. Pity!
Saturday, June 11, 2005Rating: No rosettes

Betty Ritchie
 No Pies
In spite of a sign promoting the Famous Pies Served all day At 1.30 on Monday 23 May 2005 only 2 Leek and veg pies were available because It's a Monday holiday Surely a good reason to be well stocked Will it be necessary to phone ahead now to obtain a Pie?
On behalf of a sorely disappointed pie lover
Tuesday, May 24, 2005Rating: No rosettes

Les
 EXCELLENT NON SMOKING PUB
great food and atmosphere
Wednesday, May 11, 2005Rating: rosettes

R. Lee
 Home away from home
Lived across the street at 62 Cumberland St in 1995. My favorite pub aside from being the most convenient. Good memories, good ales (especially Red McGregor). Gave me a pale of water to flush the loo one day when the pipes froze. Very cozy and traditional with friendly bar staff.

Revisited in 2003. Loved it just the same.

Thursday, May 5, 2005Rating: rosettes

Diane Sutherland
 Hope they like the look of you at Fingers
After queueing to get into Fingers Piano Bar for around 20 minutes on Friday night, my two frineds and I were told we weren't getting in because we don't want people like you in here. I would have thought 3 thirty somethings, not drunk, money to spend, on a night out were exactly who they wanted but there you go - apparently if the manager doesn't like the look of your face...... give it a miss if yuo have any reservations about it - and the toliets are disgusting!!
Tuesday, May 3, 2005Rating: rosettes

Slurper
 Typical Weaterspoons!!
Cheap food(freshly microwaved to order). Real Ales are varied at times but often poorly kept and served. Service is actually bad most of the time with poorly paid and disinterested world travellers as bar staff. Now with TVs to support Weatherspoons greed. Alcopops is definetly the word and underaged drinking encouraged!!! Popular place for getting pissed early and then moving on to better places. Budget and binge drinkers very welcome!!
Monday, May 2, 2005Rating: No rosettes

catherine latimer
 bad ass
the food was lovely but the staff were something else, we got our starter and main course together when it was not asked for and then were made to be out liars when we challenged this being told that the staff are very good and never get any orders wrong.as we went into the pub our drinks orders where taken and we ordered peach archers a member of staff came back to us and had to re-affirm the order as the waitress had put down beachams
The food is lovely but it is let down by its staff..
Sunday, April 24, 2005Rating: rosettes

Tracey Armstrong
 Good Time Had By All
Saturday Night and the The Gunners had just whitewashed The Dragons at Murrayfield. Arriving back in the City found a warm welcome, good beer and a hilarious live band who didn't stop for at least 2 hours!!!

Can't wait to go back and revisit.
Friday, April 22, 2005Rating: rosettes

B Stevenson
 Top Notch
Visit EWdinburgh about 3 times a year and never disapponted with Fingers.

Drink is quite expensive, but great atmosphere and good Criac!
Thursday, April 21, 2005Rating: rosettes

Ian
 Very Pleasant
Good food upstairs with attractive waitresses. Good range of whiskies downstairs, but staff can be a bit brisk.
Monday, April 18, 2005Rating: rosettes

dave
 nice place
been in several times have never been served.
Tuesday, April 12, 2005Rating: rosettes

P O'Connell
 2 Nights in Amityville
This hotel is worth staying at if you can take a joke. I loved every minute of the Faulty Towers charm. The rooms were clean and the food reasonable. The best bit of the trip was Rochene who worked in Hectors bar down the road. What more can I say!
Tuesday, April 12, 2005Rating: rosettes

Jamie Wylie
 Edinburgh's Best Bar & Restaurant!
Eighty Queen Street is the best bar and restaurant in Edinburgh, hands down. It's so refreshing to go in to a bar these days and not be confronted by pompous staff, trendy music and cheap and expensive food. That place has got it right! See for yourself!
Monday, April 11, 2005Rating: No rosettes

cawai
 Disappionting because of the staff
Liked th einterior design, but staff is really bad: desinterested in clients and not very friendly. Waiting for food takes ages.
Saturday, April 9, 2005Rating: No rosettes

anon
 Twatty Tastic
If Dudley and Reid are the best thing (sorry boys), you have had a miss spent time in the place. Far more interesting things go on. Well I could say right enough, if they are your heroes fanny tastic sums it up.
Tuesday, April 5, 2005Rating: rosettes

Scott
 Average
Good food, poor staff - about sums the place up. Nice sitting outside on Rose Street on a summer's day.
Monday, February 7, 2005Rating: rosettes

Scott
 Brilliant night out
Have been to The Stand three times and cannot fault the place. Best staff in Edinburgh for banter, great atmosphere, booze and comedy ... what more can you want? Superb night out.
Monday, February 7, 2005Rating: rosettes

GM
 Still great
Although refurbished, the new management is extremely welcoming. A great pub for a top-notch burger (the best in Edinburgh), or a quiet Sunday pint. Don't knock it!
Thursday, January 20, 2005Rating: rosettes

Morag
 Security are rude and heavy handed.
Yesterday a friend was mistaken for someone giving the bar-staff hassle. They took his drink from him, and told him in no uncertain terms to get out, without any explanation. When they realised their mistake, he was told he could stay, but there was no appology, and no replacement drink.
Saturday, January 8, 2005Rating: No rosettes

Simon Leadbetter
 Brilliant
I have come to Edinburgh to work for a few months and found the Antiquary to be a real home from home.The staff are attentive and friendly and the pub has a pleasant atmosphere. One down side is that a quick visit can turn into a long night without you even noticing.
Friday, November 26, 2004Rating: rosettes

Emma Speirs
 Hamiltond BLT
Myself and three friends went to Hamiltons for brunch, 3 of us chose the BLT. It costs approx £6, we were expecting something pretty ok certainly above average. It was well below this. On two slices of standard white bread (certainly no better than Safeway Savers) were two bits of bacon, two slices of tomato, a few slices of lettuce and some relish. There were some tasty wedges on the side. I felt ripped off the others agreed.
Thursday, October 28, 2004Rating: No rosettes

Scott Smyth
 Great wee bar.
Out of the way for those not in Stockbridge but well worth a visit.
Tuesday, October 26, 2004Rating: rosettes

Kathrin Mader
 Just great
The staff is very friendly and funny and the food is great, especially the dessert (the chocolat cake and the lemon sponge).
Saturday, October 16, 2004Rating: rosettes

Dirty Duff
 gonnie gizae a guiness
My bad ass burger went down a right treat, while admiring all the pics of the beatles to mr blobby (on way to toilet) big shout out to Heather behind the bar who was looking particularly fine that sunny festival day.
Saturday, October 9, 2004Rating: rosettes

PETER BARLEY
 EXCELLENTNESS
THE RECENT REFURBISHMENTS, INCLUDING NO-SMOKING AREA, FUNCTION ROOM AND THE OPENING UP OF MORE NATURAL LIGHT CHANNELS, HAVE IMPROVED THE ATMOSPHERE, AMBIENCE AND AURA OF THIS GEM OF A HIDDEN PUB.
Friday, October 1, 2004Rating: rosettes

nick
 p.s.
p.s. the url is www.thecambridgebar.co.uk now
Wednesday, September 1, 2004Rating: rosettes

nick
 cambridge bar
please update this as it is now incorrect phone number is 01312262120
and they do excellent burgers
Wednesday, September 1, 2004Rating: rosettes

FRAN N ANNA
 STILL GAME
Great wee pub full of atmosphere!!Makes a nice change fae the Clansman!!
Nice to see auld Jack n Victor at the bar most Friday nights love the cardies.. btw lads Isa has yer tea ready so ya had better drink up and move it afore she comes doon wi the rolling pin!!!
Saturday, August 21, 2004Rating: rosettes

Ronnie
 Unhappy
These guys employ backpackers for staff so they can exploit their vulnerable circumstances. They never pay their staff holiday pay, they keep the tips and pay under the minimum wage. The staff turnover there is very high. The same company own The Bad Ass next door and Clever Dicks on the Royal Mile
Sunday, August 15, 2004Rating: No rosettes

anonymous
 I worked here
Worst place i have ever worked, and that is saying something!
Friday, August 13, 2004Rating: No rosettes

Lara Stamford
 TravelStay.com
I've used TravelStay.com loads of times to book budget hotels in Edinburgh and London and never had a problem!
Thursday, July 29, 2004Rating: rosettes

ke
 great bar
Great bar griendly bar staff and locals. Good choice of beers and malts. Word of warning dont leave a toilet stop until the last minute you have been warned!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Monday, July 26, 2004Rating: rosettes

tayto
 the pub at the end of the road
a timeless wee bar at the end of a lovely new town street where you'll find good beer, good craic and really great company all taken care of by a friendly professional team. so all in all a great festival pub for pool and chat.
Sunday, July 25, 2004Rating: rosettes

Linda
 Refurbished
The Cambridge bar has been refurbished and is now under new management.
Wednesday, July 14, 2004Rating: No rosettes

George
 A must for friendliness
This must be one of THE friendliest drinking holes in Edinburgh. I keep going back when I am up from London. There are always great offers on and varied activities in evening.
Friday, July 2, 2004Rating: rosettes

VW
 Beer poor
A shadow of it's former self - relying on passing tourist trade - surly australian bar staff are rude and ill informed - sad decline for one of Edinburgh's once great pubs!
Tuesday, June 29, 2004Rating: rosettes

GRAEME HADDOW
 Stylish and contemp
The manager steven Dow is probably one of the best managers for attention to detail and customer orientation
Wednesday, June 9, 2004Rating: rosettes

Pub Spy
 V Friendly also Ferret Free
Fantastic bar in the way a pub used to be. Great staff and an eclectic bunch from gnarled locals to Yah's.
Atmosphere has recently made a great step change. Beware don't come in if you have to leave in the next fourty years.
Friday, May 28, 2004Rating: rosettes

Pub Spy
 Great Place and Ferret Free
Fine crew begind the bar, friendly folk, great atmosphere and Sunday Breakfast a joy.

Ale's good to.
Friday, May 28, 2004Rating: rosettes

Andy Collin
 First Class Boozer! What a pub SHOULD be like!
Excellent wee howf! Magical blend of customers which works well. The ale is most acceptable, as is the comely wench of a manageress, Mags, whose undivided attention to all her customers is worthy of a mention.
Saturday, May 15, 2004Rating: rosettes

Dave Moore
 Good Spot
30something crowd with live piano music open to 3am!!!
Saturday, May 8, 2004Rating: rosettes

Kym
 Simple
Basic and decent enough for the money. Similar price as a hostel but more private, we got the cheap rate on www.travelstay.com

I am only giving it a 2 because I am still trying to get a refund as I was charged twice for my room. I would advise anyone else not to pay in cash as you will also be charged to your card and it's a real headache to get money back from people...

Quite a walk to Princes Street, more like 20 mins uphill, but the buses there are frequent and cheap.
Monday, April 19, 2004Rating: rosettes

Brett Riverboat
 Too small
Bar Manager has a funny moustache.
Tuesday, April 6, 2004Rating: rosettes

kevan
 Abbotsford - Great bar
The Abbotsford in Edinburgh on Rose Street. Good atmosphere, friendly locals and good beers
Tuesday, January 20, 2004Rating: rosettes

Edinburgh Critic
 Friday Evening
Always throbbing on a Friday evening with the after office brigade. Plenty of choice of decent beers and always at least a few guest ales
Wednesday, June 12, 2002Rating: rosettes

AlexRell
 lunch time must
for a short break from working or as already stated in the description:
after shopping in those high design shops in George street, best to get over the damage on your creditcard with a bottle of chilled Chardonnay! Perfect!!!!
Tuesday, February 26, 2002Rating: rosettes


Tuesday, December 12, 2017
YOU ARE IN
EDINBURGH

Whats On

List FEATURED Pubs



FEATURE SEARCH
Real Ale
Guest Ales
Wine Selection
Restaurant
Bar Food
Country Pubs
Town/City Pubs
Scenic Pubs
Student Pubs
Quiet Pubs
Accommodation
Function Room
Open Fire Pubs
Wooden Beams
Games Room
Beer Garden
Kids Welcome
Wheelchair Access
Pets Welcome
WI-FI Access
SKY Sports TV


View the Comments



Copyright © 1999 - 2013 www.bestpubs.co.uk ltd V2.1.19